Directory
***Art & Culture***
more details coming soon
Attractions
Beckwith Christmas Tree Farm
189 Mill Street, Hannibal
​
Create a cherished memory with a trip to the Beckwith Family Christmas Tree Station for your farm fresh Christmas trees, gifts, wreaths, garland & so much more! We look forward to seeing you!
​
Ph: 315-564-5479
Email: jackandfaye@frontiernet.net
Colloca Estate
14678 West Bay Road
​
Home of Lake Effect Vineyard and Colloca Estate Winery. Colloca Estate boasts 100 acres with pristine Fair Haven Bayfront that is ideal for events and weddings.
​
Ph: 315-947-2069
Email: Monica@colloca.com
Fly-By-Night Cookie Company and Miniature Museum
14508 Fancher Avenue
Old fashioned pastry shop and miniature museum. Summer food treats and entertainment for the whole family.
​
Ph: 315-947-5588
Email: bonniebridson@twcny.rr.com
Fair Haven Beach State Park
State Park Road
​
Reservations can be made 1 days to 9 months in advance. 139 non-electric campsites, 46 electric, dump station, central restrooms with showers. 32 cabins, three cottages. Must provide own bedding and cooking utensils. 8 winterized cabins. We also have a boat launch, sandy beach on Lake Ontario, pavilions and boat rentals.
​
Ph: 315-947-5205
Fair Haven Community Arts Center
562 Main Street
​
We are a non-profit center with the mission of promoting the arts to the greater Fair Haven Area. We offer classes and hold events such as show, seminars and performances throughout the year.
​
​
Ph: 315-427-3428
Email:fairhavenart@gmail.com
Springbrook State Golf Course
817 Old State Road, Sterling
​
This 18-hole course has scenic views overlooking Sterling Marsh and Lake Ontario. Course offers both links-style holes and traditional parkland play. Available for weddings.
​
Ph: 315-947-4000
Email: ron@springbrookgreensgc.com
Sterling Nature Center
End of Jensvoldt Road, Sterling
​
1400-acres with: 2 miles of Lake Ontario shore, 5 Miles of Hiking Trails. A Diversity of Habitats; Public Programs, Picnic Shelter, Observation Decks, Exhibits, Gift Shop, Canoe Launch into Sterling Creek. Open Dawn to Dusk.
​
Ph: 315-947-6143
Email: snc@co.cayuga.ny.us
BANKING
Lyons National Bank
5996 New Hartford St., Wolcott, NY 14590
Full Service Bank servicing 7 counties by providing personal & business deposit accounts, Loans & Financial Services
​
Ph: 315-594-6002
Email: slockwood@bankwitlnb.com
Savannah Bank
563 Main Street
​
A full-service bank. Checking, savings and Christmas club accounts. Residential and commercial mortgages. Auto loans.
​
Ph: 315-947-5600
Email: rbibee@savannahbankny.com
Boats & water bikes
Fair Haven Water Bikes
King Street Boat Launch
​
There is no better way to experience Little Sodus Bay, then by a water bike!
You will be amazed at how little effort it takes to pedal as this water bike is great for fun, fitness, and sightseeing. Come for the ride, stay for the day! 90 minute rental sessions available.
​
Email: fhwaterbikes@gmail.com
Fair Haven Kayak
​
Family Kayak and SUP rental company. We deliver and pick-up all equipment in the Fair Haven area. $35/day or $100/week delivery and safety equipment included. Call ahead for delivery. Sterling Creek trips available.
​
Email: ronald.alexander@oswego.edu
facebook/profile.php?id=100057349454088
Lodging, campgrounds &VACATION RENTALS
Black Creek Farm Bed & Breakfast
13615 Mixer Rd, Red Creek, NY 13143
​
Come enjoy tranquil surroundings on spacious grounds, we’re located on a quiet country road just off our main street. We cater to people who want a breath of fresh air and a chance to get away. You can relax with the charm of the past and the comforts of today.
​
Ph: (315) 947-6242
Email: info@blackcreekfarmny.com
Fair Haven White House
14632 Fancher Ave
​
Three bedroom Two bath home with full kitchen. available for daily or weekly rental. Bayview with large yard for campfires and games.
​
Ph: (315) 529-0489
Email: johnv50@live.com
Grant's Vacation Park
Lake Street Extension
​
Grant’s Vacation Park is a seasonal family owned & operated campgrounds, located in Fair Haven Bay with water access to Lake Ontario. The sits are specially set on over 4 acres of waterfront.
​
Ph: 882-4910
Email: cgrant6@twcny.rr.com
Pleasant Beach Hotel
14477 Fancher Ave, Sterling, NY 13156
​
Bring your family, friends and come enjoy the Pleasant Beach Hotel overlooking Little Sodus Bay, just two nautical miles from the blue waters of Lake Ontario and walking distance to the village.
Ph: (315) 947-5399
Turner's 1816 House B&B
680 Main St
​
Beautifully furnished historic home in the Village of Fair Haven, peacefully situated on 3 lovely acres. Three bedrooms, each with newly renovated private bathroom. Close to walking trails, lake and right across from Fair Haven Beach State Park.
​
​
Ph: (315) 947-2028
Email: turners1816house@aol.com
Turtle Cove Resort & Marina
356 King St.
​
Turtle Cove Resort & Marina features a dockside restaurant & bar, 4 cabins with fully equipped kitchens, one cottage & beautiful apartment overlooking the water, boat slips, and boat launch. Located on beautiful Little Sodus Bay.
​
Ph: 315-947-6677
Email: infoturtlecove@gmail.com
The Village Inn
530 Main St
​
Welcome! Our 1874 Italianate Inn has 3 Queen Rooms with private bathrooms and separate guest entrance. Rooms are decorated with Mackenzie Childs furnishings, a Keurig, Wifi, smart tv and ac/heat unit. 2 rental homes that sleep up to 8 people each are also available.
​
Ph: (315)439-4433
Email: villageinnfairhaven@gmail.com
The Got-A-Way
8949 Blind Sodus Bay Road
​
Three unit motel and one single wide trailer with 3 bedroom and 2 bathroom. Nightly, weekly or monthly rentals available.
​
Ph: (315) 220-0575
Email: thegotaway@gmail.com
Camp R&R
14851 Cayuga Street
​
Quaint nautical themed cottage. 1 bedroom, 1 bath. Sleeps up to 4 with pullout couch. Outside patio furniture, firepit and off street parking. Walking distance to State Park and Beach.
​
Cell(text): (315) 391-4746
​
Marinas & Charters
Anchor Resort and Marina
14424 West Bay Road
Bed and breakfast situated on 6 acres on the south shore of Little Sodus Bay. Amenities include RV sites, cottages/vacation rental, boat slips, gas, pumpout, playground, basketball, swim and fish, family friendly.
​
Ph: (315) 947-5331
Email: anchorresort@twcny.rr.com
Fair Haven Yacht Club
14520 Westside Drive, Fair Haven
​
A group of people who enjoy sailing, racing, boating, and the friendship of a small, intimate yacht club. Whether sailing on the deep-water, (not so little) Little Sodus Bay, or the open waters of Lake Ontario (only minutes away by boat), you'll always find conditions that are just right!
​
Ph: (315) 282-0212
Turtle Cove Resort & Marina
356 King St.
​
Turtle Cove Resort & Marina features a dockside restaurant & bar, 4 cabins with fully equipped kitchens, one cottage & beautiful apartment overlooking the water, boat slips, and boat launch. Located on beautiful Little Sodus Bay.
​
Ph: 315-947-6677
Email: infoturtlecove@gmail.com
Gregg Brothers Constructions
8025 Caywood Road, Red Creek
Custom home builder & remodeler. Planning, design, complete building from start to finish. Family Business.
​
Ph: (315) 420-7936
Email: scott@greggconstruction.net
CONTRACTORS
Organizations
Cayuga County Office of Tourism
25 South Street, Auburn
​
Our research based destination marketing organization's mission is increasing economic development through tourism and visitation. Boasting the chose home of Harriet Tubman, Great Lake Ontario, three state parks and the most freshwater coastline in NYS makes it easy!
​
Ph: 315-255-1658
Email: claire@tourcayuga.com
Fair Haven Fire Department
Fair Haven Road
​
A volunteer organization providing fire protection, rescue operations and ambulance service to the Fair Haven/Sterling area.
​
Ph: 315-947-5145
​
SOFA
Fair Haven
​
A citizen organization with the purpose of sponsoring the annual Fair Haven Independence Day celebration.
​
Ph: 315-947-5701
Email: path@twcny.rr.com
​
Sterling Historical Society
Little Red School House Museum, Sterling
​
A local group dedicated to discovering and preserving information relating to the history of the Sterling/Fair Haven area. Also operates the Little Red Schoolhouse Museum. A treasure of historical information about the Fair Haven/Sterling area. Open 1-4 Saturdays and Sundays from week after July 4 to weekend before Labor Day. Other times by appointment.
​
Ph: 315-947-6461
Assembly Minority Leader Will Barclay
19 Canalview Mall
​
State Legislative Office. 120th Assembly District Representative which included Northern Cayuga County.
​
Ph: 315-598-5185
Email: barclayw@nyassembly.gov
Real estate
Century 21 Leah's Signature
566 54th Street, Fulton NY 13069
​
Welcome to Century 21 Leah's Signature, your Fair Haven Real Estate & Homes for Sales experts. Our commercial division is also available to help yo buy or sell commercial properties! We're here to help!
​
​
Ph: 315-598-1165
Email:c21leahs@aol.com
Freedom Real Estate
Real estate agency in Hannibal, New York.
​
Ph: 315-564-6300
Restaurants and taverns
Brandon's Pub
559 Main St.
Pub atmosphere with bar, restaurant and outdoor patio. Live music on weekends.
​
Ph: 315-947-6266
Email: bjlagoe@icloud.com
Colloca Estate
14678 West Bay Road
​
Home of Lake Effect Vineyard and Colloca Estate Winery. Colloca Estate boasts 100 acres with pristine Fair Haven bayfront that is ideal for events and weddings.
​
Ph: 315-947-2069
Email: Monica@colloca.com
Little Sodus Inn on the Bay
14451 Bell Avenue
Quaint waterfront bar with light food and picnic tables. Dock rentals. Two fully furnished cottages and one large summer home. The Hometown bar on the bay.
​
Ph: 315-947-9944
Hardware Cafe and General Store
566 Main St
​
Experience great local flavor in our unique, historic building in the heart of downtown Fair Haven. Serving breakfast, lunch and specialty coffee drinks; our gift shop features local products, clothing, toys, home-goods, antiques and uniques. ​
​
Ph: 315-947-6700
Email: hardware_cafe@aol.com
Pleasant Beach Hotel
14477 Fancher Ave.
Since 1910 the Historic Pleasant Beach Hotel - a Victorian Landmark - has offered waterfront dining with spectacular views.
PH: 315-947-5399
Email: pleasantbeachhotel@outlook.com
www.pleasantbeach.com
Sterling Cidery
14451 Richmond Ave
​
We're a craft cidery serving our own hard cider made using local apples on draft in a pub-style atmosphere. Growlers available for take home!
​
Ph: 315-947-4018
Stick and Rudder
574 Main St
Our Public House is a unique comfortable place to have a pint of fine craft beer, light fare, and great conversation.
Stick and Rudder is an aviation and sailing themed pub that also pays homage to Fair Haven's rich history.
​
Ph: 315-947-2108
Turtle Cove Resort & Marina
356 King St.
Turtle Cove Resort & Marina features a dockside restaurant & bar, 4 cabins with fully equipped kitchens, one cottage & beautiful apartment overlooking the water, boat slips and boat launch. Located on beautiful Little Sodus Bay.
​
Ph: 315-947-6677
Email: infoturtlecove@gmail.com
Services
Bayview Wellness Center
498 Main Street, Sterling NY 13156
Yoga, meditation, massage therapy and mental health counseling. Register for classes and book massage appointments online.
Ph: 315-591-7847
Eastern Shore Associates Insurance
101 Cayuga St., Fulton, NY
Auto, Home, Life, Business, Municipal
We are a 100% employee-owned, client-focused agency that is recognized as a trusted insurance advisor in our communities. We value long lasting relationships with our clients, built on a commitment to excellence, continual improvement and a high standard of customer service.
​
Ph: 315-598-6000
Email: kallen@esainsurance.com
Finger Lakes Financial Services, Inc.
David F. Gwynn CLU ChFC, of Finger Lakes Financial Services, Inc., provides extensive planning and advisory services. Securities offered through Grove Point Investments, LLC, member FINRA/SIPC. Investment Advisory Services offered through Grove Point Advisors, LLC. Grove Point Investments, LLC & Grove Point Advisors, LLC are subsidiaries of Grove Point Financial, LLC. Finger Lakes Financial Services, Inc. is not affiliated with Grove Point Financial, LLC or its subsidiaries.
Ph: 585-586-2600
Email: dgwynn@fifsinc.com
Fair Haven Community Church
​
We are a non-denominational Christian Church that is open to anyone to come and worship with us.
Ph: (315) 947-6233
​
Main Street Barber Shop
579 Main Street
​
A unisex barber shop in Fair Haven area specializing in all barbering services. Women's hair coloring & highlighting by appointment. All other services are walk-in only.
​
Ph: 315-947-4007
​
onePhoto Photography
State Rte 104A, Red Creek
Complete professional photographic services including weddings, portraits, commercial photography, event coverage, graphic design services and more. Local Fair Haven photography. Fine art prints for sale at several area shops as well as online.
​
Ph: 315-871-9517
Email: kyle@onephotophoto.com
Springbrook State Golf Course
817 Old State Road, Sterling
This 18-hole course has scenic views overlooking Sterling Marsh and Lake Ontario. Course offers both links-style holes and traditional parkland play. Available for weddings.
​
Ph: 315-947-4000
Email: ron@springbrookgreensgc.com
Nature's Palette Photography Art
9415 Ingersoll Drive, Sterling
​
Ellen Gerberich is a local artist and author. Her work can be seen at South Shore Artisans in Fair Haven or on her website or www.etsy.com/shop/naturespaletteart
​
Ph: 315-947-6934
Email: naturespalette@twcny.rr.com
Wayuga Printing & Publishing
6784 Main Street, Red Creek
Established in 1965. We publish our own weekly Lakeshore News & Wayuga Shopper. As well as other outside publications. In house commercial printing brochures, newsletters, business cards, envelope printing, comprehensive finishing and more!
​
Ph: 315-754-6229
Email: chuck.palermo@wayuga.com
Shopping
Bayside Grocery
537 Main Street
Bayside is a grocery store with a deli, fresh meat, and alcohol sections. We sell cigarettes, lottery, and fill propane tanks. We also carry many hardware and camping items. Come in and try a sub or a pizza soon!
​
Ph: 315-947-5708
Email: baysidegroc@gmail.com
The Front Porch
578 Main Street
Large selection of gifts, decor and souvenirs, including Fair Haven t-shirts, sweatshirts & memorabilia. Charming antique and vintage collections for one-of-a-kind gifts and treasures.
Open April-Dec.
Ph: 315-947-5000
Email: 4frontporch@gmail.com
Hardware Cafe and General Store
566 Main St
​
Experience great local flavor in our unique, historic building in the heart of downtown Fair Haven. Serving breakfast, lunch and specialty coffee drinks; our gift shop features local products, clothing, toys, home-goods, antiques and uniques. ​
​
Ph: 315-947-6700
Email: hardware_cafe@aol.com
onePhoto Photography
State Rte 104A, Red Creek
Complete professional photographic services including weddings, portraits, commercial photography, event coverage, graphic design services and more. Local Fair Haven photography. Fine art prints for sale at several area shops as well as online.
​
Ph: 315-871-9517
Email: kyle@onephotophoto.com
Ontario Orchards
Rte 104 West, Oswego
A family-owned farm stand featuring a variety of fresh produce, plants, nursery stock, baked goods and much more. Pick-your-own fruits. Annual fall jamboree. Open year around.
​
Ph: 315-343-6328
Email: info@ontarioorchards.com
South Shore Artisans
567 Main St
A collection of local artists with a variety of mediums including oils, watercolors, graphics, jewelry, wood turned items, fabric arts, ceramics, and mosaics.
​
Phone: 315-532-4378
Email: naturespalette@twcny.rr.com
Red's West End
475 Main Street
Check out our monthly specials Featuring non-ethanol 91, AMSOIL, firewood, ice, ATM, Lotto, beer, soda, grocery items. Fresh-made subs and pizzas. Bait shop-live bait, lures, poles. Camping and ERV supplies. Fast & Friendly!
​
Ph: 315-947-6900
Email: redswestend@gmail.com
Parkside Store
638 7th Street
​
Fair Haven's Parkside store offers live bait, firewood, beer, ice and camping supplies you may have forgotten. We've got what you forgot. Located just outside the State Park entrance on 7trh Street.
​
Ph: 919-201-3816
Email: parksidestore2017@gmail.com
weddings
Black Creek Farm Barn Venue
13615 Mixer Rd, Red Creek, NY 13143
The property has everything you need for an unforgettable wedding weekend. Includes the country colonial farmhouse, the perennial gardens, a gazebo with trickling stream with pond, the barn venue, the hair studio and a collection of ceremony sites to choose from.
​
Ph: (315) 947-6242
Email: info@blackcreekfarmny.com
Colloca Estate
14678 West Bay Road
Home of Lake Effect Vineyard and Colloca Estate Winery. Colloca Estate boasts 100 acres with pristine Fair Haven bayfront that is ideal for events and weddings.
​
Ph: 315-947-2069
Email: Monica@colloca.com
Pleasant Beach Hotel
14477 Fancher Ave.
Since 1910 the Historic Pleasant Beach Hotel - a Victorian Landmark - has offered waterfront dining with spectacular views.
PH: 315-947-5399
Email: pleasantbeachhotel@outlook.com
www.pleasantbeach.com
Springbrook State Golf Course
817 Old State Road, Sterling
​
This 18-hole course has scenic views overlooking Sterling Marsh and Lake Ontario. Course offers both links-style holes and traditional parkland play. Available for weddings.
​
Ph: 315-947-4000
Email: ron@springbrookgreensgc.com